疑

Traditionally analyzed as a compound ideograph with a long graphic evolution.

In oracle inscriptions (甲骨文), 疑 depicts a person (大) holding a staff, with the head tilted, as if hesitating or unsure.

This image represents someone wandering, unsure of direction, from which the core idea “to hesitate / to be uncertain” arose.

In Bronze inscriptions (金文 jinwen) additional elements were introduced:

彳 (“to walk slowly”)

止 (“to stop”)

These reinforce the idea of hesitant movement while traveling.

At this stage, 牛 (ox) also appears possibly as a phonetic element, or symbolically, as in “having lost one’s ox”, implying confusion or anxiety.

In Small seal script (小篆) major structural changes occur, 彳 disappears.

The hesitating person becomes a form resembling a reversed 匕 (dagger) combined with 矢 (arrow).

牛 is replaced by 子 (child)

The character becomes more abstract, moving away from pictorial depiction.

In Clerical script (隸書) and Regular script the strokes flatten and simplify, resulting in the modern form 疑.

Semantic development:

- hesitation while moving

- uncertainty of direction

- mental confusion

- doubt, suspicion

- questioning or inquiry

Thus, 疑 shifts from physical hesitation to intellectual doubt.

疑心 (의심) — doubt; suspicion

質疑 (질의) — inquiry; formal questioning

疑問 (의문) — question; doubt

猜疑 (추의) — suspicion; mistrust

懷疑 (회의) — skepticism

疑 does not necessarily imply accusation; it can indicate neutral intellectual uncertainty.

In contrast, words like 嫌疑 or 疑犯 lean toward criminal suspicion.

Philosophical and scholarly texts frequently use 疑 positively, as critical inquiry.

The original imagery emphasizes movement blocked by uncertainty, a metaphor still meaningful today.

In Classical Chinese, 疑 frequently expresses epistemic uncertainty rather than accusation.

疑而不決 — “to doubt and be unable to decide”

疑其言 — “to doubt his words”